top of page

Vaccines & the Pandemics/Epidemics In The Past. Will a vaccine be the final ultimatum for Covid-19?

Writer: Jessica Khin
Jessica Khin
Aug 22, 2020
10 min read

Updated: Aug 28, 2020

This is a research paper on the question;"Have Vaccines Saved Us During Pandemics and Epidemics In The Past?".


Polio, Diphtheria, and even the once-deadly Smallpox are some of the diseases that have put the whole of mankind in devastation.


In those centuries, we might have thought we would’ve never made it out. Some pandemics, such as The Black Death, or the Spanish Flu, were considered “God’s punishment for our deadly sins”, “witchcraft” and the “end of the world”.


Once medicine developed, doctors started to have an idea about how diseases spread, and one man’s virtuosity helped discover vaccinations: a single shot of antigens which stimulate production of antibodies as an immune response.


Vaccinations could eradicate the deadliest of epidemics, an invention that played a vital role to the advancement of medicine. There’s an abundance of diseases we may have disregarded about today, thanks to vaccinations.


The Research Question


First and foremost, the research question is to find out, in detail, about some examples of diseases/epidemics cured by vaccinations. Since there are opposing arguments to be made for either side, this paper will also be highlighting pandemics and epidemics that were not necessarily eradicated entirely by vaccinations, although they may have played a role.

Although one might find looking at the history of devastating events purposeless, it could make them aware of the importance of vaccinations and the contributions and lessons given in regards to this current global tragedy, the COVID-19 pandemic.


This research paper will give us an idea about how we can continue to fight this virus the way we have overcome those obstacles in the past, and why it is not easy to produce a vaccine despite the advanced medicine technology and facilities we have today in the year 2020.


Discovery of Vaccines During The Small Pox Epidemic - 1796


The invention of vaccinations dates back to 1796 during the smallpox epidemic, in an era where a country doctor named Edward Jenner decided to test a theory drawn from folklore from the countryside: that milk maids were not infected by the deadly smallpox virus which infected nearly everyone.

Cowpox was a viral skin infection and was a lot milder than smallpox. The Cowpox would originate from the cows and was passed on to the milkmaids. The fact that milkmaids were immune to smallpox sparked an interest in Edward Jenner and made him test this theory on how cowpox granted immunity to smallpox. To commence, Jenner found a boy named James Phipps who had never suffered from any cowpox or smallpox before.


Taking a pustule from the milkmaid’s cowpox infection, he put it into an incision on James’s arm. Phipps fell mildly ill after this, but after a week, he recovered. Jenner then procured the pus from a smallpox victim and gave James the disease. Jenner’s theory was then proven when James didn’t contract smallpox.

The research paper was submitted to the Royal Society but was criticized for not being backed up with sufficient evidence. Therefore, Jenner tested this experiment out on more children. The paper, now supported with more evidence, was published, and today, vaccination continues to play a role in the advancement of medicine.

The Poliomyelitis Epidemic- 1894

(if you’ve read my post about Polio you might want to skip some parts- I recapped this for some background knowledge for a clear understanding)


What is Poliomyelitis? One may be familiar with the disease by the name of Polio, perhaps from a childhood memory of being dragged to a vaccination campaign held locally, drinking a sweet substance from a small vessel, and being overjoyed at the fact that no needles were involved in the process, in contrast to other vaccinations.

Poliomyelitis is caused by a poliovirus, reproduced by itself in the gut and further spreading to the nervous system, resulting in paralysis, or death. There is unfortunately no cure for poliomyelitis.

The first outbreak of polio as an epidemic started in 1894 in Vermont, USA with 132 cases, followed by a much more serious epidemic of polio in 1916. The poliovirus goes through towns almost every summer with no warning.

Polio is transmitted through nasal or oral secretions. It enters the body through the mouth, and further multiplies in the digestive tract. 98% of polio victims suffer a mild illness with no symptoms. However, a minority of patients suffer from paralytic polio, where the poliovirus enters the bloodstream, attacking the nerve cells. Severe cases of this attack could result in the throat and chest being paralyzed, which often leads to death if there is no artificial breathing support is provided.


The eradication of polio

To answer the research question, the poliomyelitis epidemic came to an end when a vaccine was discovered.

Jonas Salk, a medical researcher began to work with his mentor, Thomas Francis Jr at the University of Michigan. Their first research was about developing a vaccine for the influenza virus, which used a killed-virus principle; the same principle used to develop the vaccine for polio. This means the vaccine was not virulent but would still induce antibodies. Salk applied the same killed-virus principle to develop a polio vaccine.

However, large amounts of poliovirus were needed in order to produce a vaccine. The solution was met when it was discovered that poliovirus could grow in tissue cultures of non-nerve tissues - as ascertained by John Enders, Thomas Weller, and Frederick Robbins. This meant that Salk wouldn’t need to inject live monkeys to produce large sums of the poliovirus. Cultures of monkey kidney cells were still used to grow the three types of poliovirus. The grown polioviruses were then killed with formaldehyde and the first trial of the vaccine was tested successfully on a monkey, followed by trials on humans.

Salk’s successful development was a killed vaccine. At this era, the majority of researchers believed that live vaccines gave an extended time of immunity even if it was virulent and came with risks.

Albert Sabin, who was a firm believer of this, decided to develop an attenuated live virus vaccine alongside Salk. Sabin performed autopsies on people who have died of polio. He decided to make the vaccine an oral vaccine, as it was easier to administer than an injection. Tests of virus strains were carried out and Sabin established 3 mutated strains of the virus, which induced antibodies, but did not cause paralysis. The Soviet Union health ministry conducted a field trial and the US Public Health Service approved the vaccine. Soon, Sabin’s oral vaccine dominated Salk’s killed-virus vaccine despite controversies of the live oral vaccine causing polio paralysis.

Presently, we are aware that the polio vaccine branches out into two types; the oral polio vaccination (OPV) and the inactivated polio vaccination (IPV).

The OPV is predominant and acquires contact immunity where vaccinated individuals confer immunity to the unvaccinated ones through contact. However, the downsides of OPV include rare cases where the vaccinated individuals, especially those who are immuno-compromised, contract polio. The IPV does not relate to this issue.

This led to the eradication of poliovirus through supplementary routine immunization campaigns, and careful surveillance of the virus. Statistically speaking, cases dropped from 8000 instances of paralytic polio every year in the UK to a rapid fall of cases until the last case in 1984. Polio has now been eradicated in the UK and most parts of the world.


Diphtheria Epidemic (if you’ve read my post about Diphtheria you might want to skip some parts- I recapped this for some background knowledge for a clear understanding)

Being the 3rd leading cause of death in children in England and Wales, the diphtheria epidemic lasted from 1921 to 1925 and peaked in 1921 with a shocking total of 206,000 cases, just in the USA.

Diphtheria is a highly contagious bacterial disease, causing inflammation of the mucous membrane, and formation of a false membrane in the throat, which makes breathing problematic for the victim. This could lead to fatal heart damage.

In a treatment discovered by Joseph O’Dwyer, tubes were inserted into the throat of the patient. These tubes allowed the victim to breathe, as the false membrane obstructed airways. Antibiotics are also used in the diphtheria treatment.


Unlike any other vaccines, the diphtheria “vaccine” is quite unique. Emil von Behring developed an antitoxin taken from animal blood. The antitoxin neutralized all toxic substances released from the bacterium but did not actually kill the bacterium. Clotting agents were removed from the antitoxin and injected into patients. So technically, it is not a vaccine like any other diseases, as this does not involve the injection of antigens from the responsible pathogen. However it is still referred to as a vaccine.

When the ‘vaccine’ was initially introduced to the UK in 1942, there were a total of 55,000 cases each year with nearly 3500 deaths per year. Currently, there is only 4 deaths in the UK in the past 20 years, proving the effectiveness of Behring’s discovery, making diphtheria a disease of the past by implementation of massive vaccination programmes.


The Black Death-1346-1353


“Bless you,” one says as the other sneezes. This commonly used expression is derived from the most fatal pandemic recorded in history and was thought to prevent the person from dying, as sneezing was one of the symptoms of the plague.

The Black Death, or the Bubonic Plague, was caused by a bacteria originating in Asia, spreading from fleas of black rats on merchant ships. The first outbreak started when one of the ships arrived in Europe with sailors at death’s door, with pus oozing from black boils under armpits and groin. The bacteria attack the lymphatic system, which causes these swellings in lymph nodes.


Doctors at this time had no understanding of biology and civilians were extremely superstitious thinking this is “God’s punishment” which made them purge communities. Doctors were also irrational and provided unsophisticated treatments such as rosewater baths, bloodletting, and boil-lancing which were unsanitary.

After deaths of 75 to 200 million people, the black death came to an end through implementation of quarantines and improvement of personal hygiene and as healthcare professionals learnt how to deal with proximity such as isolating arriving sailors at the docks until they are proven healthy.


Spanish Flu-1918


Deadliest in the history of epidemics, emerging cycle by cycle every year is the influenza H1N1 flu pandemic, infecting one third of the world’s population. Although it is referred to as “Spanish Flu”, it did not originate in Spain and the geographical origin is not identified.

The virus is spread through respiratory droplets by sneezing and coughing. It affects the respiratory system and victims develop flu-like symptoms such as chills, fever, and fatigue.


Since the virus broke out during war, the war would reduce people’s resistance and weaken their immune system by malnourishment. This mainly affected the immunosuppressed soldiers whose resistance was weak from war stress, combat attacks, and chemical attacks.

The first wave of the virus was a typical flu epidemic where the most at risk were the elderly-just like the current COVID-19 pandemic. Younger people would recover early although this is not the case as following cycles also killed young people with strong immune systems.


Conversely, the second wave in 1918 holds the record of having the highest fatality rate of all the cycles after the virus mutated to a deadlier form. Victims would die within hours as their skin turn blue and their lungs fill with fluid, making them gasp for air.


Normal civilians were told to stay home if they were very ill and the mildly ill were allowed to continue their routines, which discernibly could spread the virus. Down in the trenches, soldiers with mild strain stayed in while the very ill ones were sent to crowded hospitals via jam-packed trains, which unquestionably subsidized to a wider spread of the virus.


The Spanish Flu made a third vengeance, hitting Australia in 1919, but this was less severe than the second cycle, though deadlier than the first. The last cycle was minor and fortunately had a low mortality rate.


One thought invading people’s minds may be, “What are medical professionals doing? Develop a vaccine like every other pandemic!”


Unfortunately, the Flu mutated each year and when they did get a vaccine for one strain, the vaccine didn’t work for the mutated form of the next. To add to this issue, Spanish flu was also a virus: a smaller pathogen than bacteria, and at the time, the only tools available were just able to detect bacteria.


After 4 cycles of complete misery, medics began to understand how the virus worked and became more effective in prevention and treatment, leading to implementation of strict quarantines, which slowly stopped the spread of the virus. This meant that the Spanish flu wasn’t a disease necessarily saved by vaccinations, but through other methods, similar to The Black Death.

Covid-19 Pandemic-2020


In regards to the COVID-19 pandemic, we are aware that quarantines have been implemented in parts of the world with strict social distancing rules. The previous pandemics; Spanish Flu and the Black Death help understand the effectiveness of implementing quarantines. Lockdowns are placed, isolation programmes are made for travellers, and sanitation guidelines are advertised over the Internet or in posters, to help prevent the spread but the pandemic still hasn't come to an end. With today’s technology, medics and researchers are fully aware of how the virus works, unlike the pandemics of the past. Having read the recent paragraphs on how a vaccination could potentially save an epidemic, a vaccine sounds like the final ultimatum to end this.

Online Interview


However, even with today’s technology and knowledge, researchers still struggle to find a vaccine for coronavirus. I had interviewed a doctor online on “Why do you think it is difficult to find a vaccine for COViD-19?”

“D614G is one of the antigens from SARS-CoV-2 that mutated and enhance the infectivity of the virus and it is the spike protein which makes the virus easier to attach to the host cell. So what I was trying to say is that what if on-going mutation changes the virus into another variant that even the successful vaccination can’t detect and prevent it anymore. On the other hand, production of vaccination needs 6 steps, and a lot of time is required to proceed between each step. Most vaccines for coronavirus are now in Phase 2 or 3 at the most. We have to cover all 6 phases to make a successful vaccine. For instance, scientists have tried to produce the HIV vaccine but they failed after phase 3. At the same time, antivirals are also expected to give some bright hope according to BBC News where an antiviral shortens recovery time for patients with coronavirus. So all in all, scientists believed that even after great efforts were offered we might not achieve what we hoped.” -Doctor Oak Kaung Zan


Conclusion


In conclusion, vaccines may not be the answer to every single disease, but they still continue to be an essential part of healthcare and medical research. As shown in the examples explored above, many devastating health crises may have turned out to be even more fatal if not for the efforts put into vaccines and their virtues. On the other hand, other alternative solutions could appear, which is better than vaccines. It seems like the majority’s final hope to end this current cataclysm are vaccines but from what we can learn from this paper, perchance divergent solutions could arise.

Comments


© 2023 by Closet Confidential. Proudly created with Wix.com

bottom of page