Solving Yangon's Stray Dog Problem ; a response to the Guardian article 'I want to kill these dogs'
This is my personal response to the Guardian article, please have a read before proceeding.
The question of whether to cull strays divides Yangon. The problems related to these dogs have become inevitable as cases of violent dog attacks and rabies have rapidly increased. Nonetheless, I am astounded by how the responsible authorities are using the old conservative methods of culling. Is culling a really effective way to end this problem of street dogs? The authorities need to give time to think, as this method of ridding the dogs has been ineffective for more than half a century. Ask the authorities whether culling has lowered the number of strays. The more disturbing fact is that the majority of citizens, as mentioned by Ye Naung Thein, have been a pillar of strength to this inhumane system.
Culling by poisoning is a very ferocious way to kill as the animals suffer before they die. Poisoning may be secondary to what I would like to say. The question of how effective this method is my concern. Deciding to cull is a fail at the first hurdle. In a country with Buddhists being 88% of the population, I am startled how there are more religious complaints on how the spay and neuter program is so sinful in comparison to culling. Rahul Sehgal, a respected member from the HIS, states, “If you compare the statistics of rabies …number of rabies cases”. Even if one drives around a single neighborhood, there is still the presence of a dime a dozen stray dogs, evidence that culling is ineffectual. The spay and neuter program does takes time, and of course, slower than slaughtering a living being with weapons and poisoning them. If only the citizens have patient minds, even other great committees such as the Soi Dog Foundation and Rahul Sehgal’s own team, the HSI, are willing to help, as stated by Ye Naing Thein. They are also the ones that solved analogous problems in the past including Thailand’s stray dog problem. It worked because the citizens trusted the professionals. Why can’t we do the same thing?
Moreover, the streets are still occupied with unvaccinated stray dogs. This is as precarious as having a Covid positive patient meander on the streets without a mask. Citizens are terrified to walk home, and mothers like San Thar Myint, are petrified to let their kids play alone, making the future generation less independent. Additionally, neighborhoods complain about disturbing howls at midnight.
Daw Khin Than Mon, a medical superintendent from Yangon General Hospital has also remarked on a total of 41 patients that died last year from the incurable rabies disease, as she predicts even more deaths incoming this year. Spaying and neutering and vaccinating these stray dogs will reduce complaints that the committee receives each day and will make Yangon a securer place. In the United States, there are 4.5 million dog bite victims per year, the majority being children. However, even if this solution is virtuous, adults like San Thar Myint should also be aware of this danger and should be able to protect their kids.
Myanmar is known as the golden city, a Buddhist country, and rich in culture. It is ludicrous how this city will be seen as a bloody lair of scattered corpses of strays. It is more absurd how Buddhists are aware that this culling is sinful, but they support it as they think there is no other solution. As Rahul Sehgal has mentioned, it is a knee-jerk reaction. We know the symptoms, yet not finding the solution. Think about the tourists, who see pictures of beautiful pagodas, and have decided to pay a visit. They wouldn’t be exultant to see such bloodiness, brutality, and inhumaneness in such a reverential country of pure tradition, and culture.
Consider also, the image we would get if they pass on to their friends or family at home, how malicious this country is. It gives overall a debauched image and reputation, demolishing all the treasurable tradition that we have preserved until today.
Overall, I think that we should put this callous culling to an end. The current dogs have a life expectancy of around 10 years. After this batch has ended, we will make Yangon a safer place to live in and give a good image to our country, which has huge potential of developing. As the city council, it is also part of the committee to allegedly advance the country, and culling will never be a great start.


Comments