The Great Asian Puppet Show
Updated: Aug 22, 2020
Disclaimer: This was written from the point of view of an Asian student with conservative parents who give no choice in what the student wanted to pursue. Bits in this essay reflects on what some Asian families are really like. This essay is not fully personal.
“Mum, I’m sorry I was careless, but half of my class got worse grades than I did.”
“Don’t talk back to your elders, and so what, your friend got an A*, it’s merely because you didn’t study at all, and that your intellect is that of a prawn’s.”
Louis-Vuitton handbags, discussing children’s achievements and universities, Oxford, Yale, Harvard; typical Asian parents expect their children to be prodigies who learn how to play the hardest Beethoven Sonata at the age of 5. They feel the need to forever compare us to our peers, make us feel like we’re under a microscope, as well as to plan OUR lives. As a teenager, I may not be an expert on this topic, as I am too ‘young’ to give a rational opinion regarding this topic, but please, hear me out.
Intelligence. When people see the Asian race, this is what they see, and it’s not far from being correct. If you look at us, we’re doctors, lawyers, engineers, and any other one of those classic career options. And usually in Asian culture, it’s the parents who decide our careers. I mean, I know there are some who actually want to pursue one of those archetypal career options due to interest, but there are SO many cries of adolescents that are forced to pursue a career not of their choice. Soon, I will be on my way to university and trust me, without a soothsayer, I can say there’s going to be countless discussions on what I should pursue.
“Spare the rod and spoil the child", how could we forget this saying and the infamous, Asian beating, starring the typical household items such as broomsticks, belts, canes, sit-ups, or the natural way of pinching, and pulling of ears? So, what actually makes it more upsetting is that these come from people who want the best for you. Your mum hits you to make you a “better person” and to teach you manners, and your loathed tuition teacher makes you do 100 sit-ups if you get below 90%. Sure, that is the reason why you get good grades! However, consider this: would bruising my skin make my IQ higher, and change the grade that’s written on the front cover? Or would making me evaluate my mistakes, and using that time to tutor me, help me more?
So, what do we want? Young adolescents want freedom to be themselves and have some say in what they want to do. Parents need to understand that to pursue one’s career, one should do what he or she is passionate in. This demands trust on their part.
A child will never learn to walk if parents insist on carrying it around. In the western world, a baby is kept in its own room since the time it is born. Little children climb monkey bars and ride bicycles without their mothers beside them. They fall, bruise themselves but they learn and are able to grow up to be independent individuals, leaving home, fully matured at the age of 18. So why can we not be treated the same way?
Consider Bentham’s theory of the calculus between pain and pleasure. Imagine a scale with pain on the right and the pleasure on the left. The pain of these stifled teenagers, which includes attending a university as a fulfillment of a duty, would go on the right. On the day of the graduation, the parents will be holding their heads up, proud of “their achievement”. The pleasure? Maybe getting astronomical salaries is an exception, but is it worth it? What if the parents end up regretting it when the child gets depressed and commits suicide, due to this[1]? Thus, it is not considered morally correct, as the pain outweighs the pleasure, according to Bentham.
Put yourselves in the shoes of a teenager. Would you want to be that puppet held by strings? A juvenile would want to cut off all the strings and do away with the puppeteer if he or she can. It would be ideal to dance by oneself.
[1] Huffington post: suicide rates for teen boys and girls are climbing
Accessed (May 28, 2018)
[1] Huffington post: suicide rates for teen boys and girls are climbing https://www.huffingtonpost.com/entry/suicide-rates-teen-girls_us_59848b64e4b0cb15b1be13f4 Accessed (May 28, 2018)

Comments